The last piece here is a live one: my Signal Flow performance at Mills, followed by notes on criticism and expectation.

“White Like Me” was my Signal Flow piece, performed live in Littlefield Concert Hall for my MFA in music performance at Mills.

As it played out, the piece could be considered part of the improvised music scene of players like Wayne Krantz. It is based on groove and expanded tonality, using shifting pulse, meter, and subdivision along with the chromatic scale. Its phrasing is rooted in post-bebop and draws on funk, but with displaced beats.

The title “White Like Me” comes from Tim Wise’s book White Like Me: Reflections on Race from a Privileged Son (2005), a personal account of white privilege and racism in America whose own title borrows from John Howard Griffin’s Black Like Me.

Wayne Krantz said, “If we can agree on something in one moment ….playing bebop is affirming a tradition that’s a little different than improvising. We all know what good bebop is, so when we play bebop we are affirming a tradition…”

I’ve spent most of my life rehearsing and practicing. Rehearsing is standard when preparing for a gig, even though at many gigs the music is set by a shared repertoire. For this performance, I didn’t want that, which is why I was happy no rehearsal happened. The music was truly about that moment, good or bad, and about the anxiety and confusion of dealing with it.

Concert tradition is funny to me. The audience sits still and listens to the people on stage… I was happy that Tara yelled out “Go, Khalil!” That’s all I really wanted: to connect with my musicians and the audience. In a way, Tara really made it for me; she made it complete.

She broke the barrier between performers and audience. I want performance to be a group activity, with yelling, dancing, and so on, not unlike Oliveros’s Deep Listening performances.

Nothing about this piece was discussed or rehearsed. I hired musicians based on my experience playing with them; they had never met each other. Valentino and I sang rhythmic ideas to each other for about five minutes before the performance. The piece received mixed reviews. Some thought it suffered from a lack of rehearsal, some found it meandering and too wide-ranging, and others felt it was too traditional. For Valentino and me, a real truth and connection evolved over the course of the performance, as we confirmed to each other afterward. Michael felt a little uncomfortable, but anxiety is a beautiful thing. I had played with both of them in a variety of settings and styles, and I chose them for Signal Flow for a specific reason. I had mixed feelings about rehearsing and was glad that scheduling conflicts prevented it.

For this piece, I didn’t want anything getting in the way of the truth of that moment: that moment, in that space, with that audience. A game plan might have produced a more “structured” or “successful” piece, but for me that would have been a failure.

The piece was about being myself on stage for what was supposed to be 20 minutes. I later learned that the lighting technician hadn’t followed my instructions, which were to kill the lights abruptly after twenty minutes. Instead, he waited 25 minutes and slowly faded them out; he felt uncomfortable cutting the lights while we were still playing. I had wanted a bold, subversive gesture to shut us up. But intention must always be sacrificed.

Intention has to be played by the music, shaped, reborn, and dictated by it. How quickly can you let go of intention, as a listener and as a player? How quickly can you let go of judgment and expectation?

On Criticism

“your opinion of me is none of my business” –Tiffany Austin

Paraphrasing Pat Metheny (Pryor, 2002): There are times when people love my work, and times when they don’t… I’m always happy if they enjoy it. But none of that has anything to do with my process; I’m my own worst critic. I’m not going to try to guess what you want to hear or what others might like. That would be dishonest. All I can do is satisfy the music fan inside of me.

Metheny has said that he follows one compass only, the fan and listener that lives inside of him: “It is really important to stay to the fan that is within you” (Pryor, 2002).

Satisfying the music fan inside of me is my measure of success.

I enjoy reading negative criticism of well established musicians

Cecil Taylor has been criticized by people on youtube

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cP5L8tjnB6w.

andifyouhadtwocoats -“makes about as much sense as a wet fart”

Another internet troll about a Cecil Taylor piece “all those people who liked this must be on some serious drugs.. if this thing is a masterpiece, than i am the zombified corpse of jimi hendrix, just resting here and laughing at this asshole”

Professor Roscoe Mitchell has also received internet criticism

“ He needs to learn how to play the saxophone”

I expect to be criticized.

Someone once said, “Your opinion of me is none of my business.”