A lot of possibilities exist for new harmonic movement. Departing from strict diatonicism and embracing the options presented by modal borrowing, we can allow for the existence of multiple tritones in a key. Tritone substitution might be seen as the first hint at symmetrical harmony or multi-tonic tonality.

Who organizes chromatic harmony into a complete system? Is it accomplished by examining all possible modal borrowing and symmetrical options? I spend a lot of time thinking about music theory, particularly the possibility of a twelve-tone tonality, finding irregular chord changes that appeal to me. But how can these concepts be explained to the lay person, and what is their greater meaning?

Currently, the popular way to refer to chord changes references tonality. For example, II m7-V7-Imaj, or I-IIm-IIIm-IV-V-VIm- VIIm7b5—all directly reference the major scale. A new chromatic language would offer the harmonic possibilities of all twelve tones —

(I(C)-II(C#)-III (D)-IV (D#)-V(E)-VI(F)-VII(F#)-VIII(G)-IX(G#)- X(A)-XI(A#)-XII(B)). In this system a two-five-one would be stated as: IIIm7(Dmin7)-VIII7(G7)-Imaj7.

Making a clear distinction between tonal center and scale, I accept Schoenberg’s idea that there should be 12 chromatic keys rather than 12 major and 12 minor keys. Chords like Db-9, Eb-9, and Gmaj7, for example, should be considered part of the key of C.

Secondary dominants and their related II chords, tritone substitutes and their related II chords, and the full use of modal borrowing together make it possible to maintain any key center through any chord built on any note of the chromatic scale. These secondary dominants, tritone substitutes, and related II chords should therefore be examined in relation to the key in which they actually occur. As it stands, they are treated as chords that don’t belong to their key, and that understanding limits the ways they can function. They don’t need to resolve to their “target” chords; they can be used in ways that involve no tonicization or “minimodulation.”

As Pat Metheny suggests, any note can be part of any chord, and the strongest evidence for this comes from the overtone series.

Consider a Cmaj13 chord, with the tones C, E, G, B, D, and A. The strongest and most prominent feature of each tone is its perfect fifth, the first different tone of the overtone series. When we play a Cmaj13, each of those tones sounds its own perfect fifth, so C, E, G, B, D, and A also give us G, F#, D, A, and E. If we consider the next different note of the overtone series, the major third, our original chord of C, E, G, B, D, and A also gives us E, G#, B, Eb, F#, and Db. So when we sound a Cmaj13, we are in fact hearing C, E, G, B, D, A, F#, Db, and Eb. In this way we can expand our Cmaj13 to include all twelve tones. We could also examine the third different overtone of each pitch. The b7 would give us more chromatic tones, and we could play in our Cmaj13 some of the tones implied by the original pitches, such as the F#, which is the first different overtone of B and the second of D. If we play the F#, its first different overtone is Db, and its second is Bb. That brings the b7 (Bb) into our Cmaj13 chord.

The music of Ben Monder further exemplifies the theories I have discussed here. Monder stands at the avant-garde of 21st century music, a music we have only begun to explore.

My own contribution to this exploration is the attempt to uncover the function of every chromatic chord within a key, and to fully work out the existing understanding of how chromatic pitches function in tonality. Which pitches point to dominant function, and which to subdominant and tonic function? In our fully chromatic world, which chords substitute for the II, which for the V, and which for the I? I believe we have to reexamine our notions of function in order to describe current and historical practice, the music as it actually sounds, accurately, and to clear a path for future methods not yet realized.

I like the concept of imaginary numbers: numbers that don’t exist but result from operations on very real numbers. “An imaginary number is a number that can be written as a real number multiplied by the imaginary unit i, which is defined by its property i2 = −1. The square of an imaginary number bi is −b2” (Wikipedia).

Some things can’t be seen, but we know they exist by observing other particles. In music and art, what came before us is a glimpse of the whole: something we can see that tells us something we can’t see is there.

In the same way, tonality and tonal theory can be viewed as constructs that point to an order we don’t yet understand. We know this order exists, but we know it only through our tonality and our concepts of tonality. As we evolve, so do our concepts; in each moment we see more and learn more about what we can’t see. In early views of tonality, chromaticism is a small part of something larger, or a tool that helps us understand that there is a larger order.

One theory of gravity suggests that gravity affects other dimensions. We can’t see those dimensions, but we think they exist because gravity appears to be weaker in our dimension than it should be.

An interesting experiment, first done in the 1800s, showed that people find a composite of many faces more attractive than any single real face. The experiment was repeated more recently by computer: when an average face is blended from many faces, people are generally more attracted to that fictional composite than to any specific real face.

In Haiti, enslaved people from different regions of Africa were mixed together. As a result, they created depictions of spirits that were composites of the spirits of every tribe, so that all could relate to the images and no tribe’s spirituality was favored over another’s.

The “wisdom of the crowd” shows the same phenomenon. A bowl of jelly beans sits at the front of a class, and each student guesses how many jelly beans are in it. Time and again, the average of all the guesses is more accurate than the individual guesses.

I’m just one version of a mixed-ethnicity man, born in Berkeley, California, in 1973, who took up the guitar at 13 and has been playing ever since. We are versions of people existing through time and space. Pat Metheny has said that the musicians he responds to most “show something about who they are, where they’re from, what they love in music” (Reed, 2018), and that is what we are. But we are also variations of one another, each with our own role: separate individuals who form a not-so-separate collective, tempering individualism with a more communal appreciation. File sharing, sharing on the Internet, sharing ideas with people around the world, access to enormous amounts of information across time and space. I believe that art matters, that all artists matter, and that all artists are connected. I believe that a community of artists spanning space and time gives rise to great work. We all know Picasso painted his works as an individual, but it is our collective that is truly responsible for that work and all work: each of us exploring, developing, practicing, and creating year after year, not just to express our individualism but to express our collectivism.

As Roscoe Mitchell put it: “We are dealing with a situation where something that is true in one environment is not true in another.”

Are there universal truths? Can two conflicting realities be reconciled?